Utterers meaning and intentions and moves to an iterative account. These two lectures were initially published as utterer s meaning and intentions in 1969 and utterer s meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning in 1968, and were later collected with the other lectures as the first section of studies in the way of words in 1989. Meaning, maxims of communication and language games 7 one can, for example, induce another to make space on a park bench by edging towards them instead of asking them to move. Grice s theory is further developed in utterers meaning and intention, 78 phil. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Starting with the assumption that the notion of an utterer s occasion meaning can be explicated, in a certain way, in terms of an utterer s intentions, i argue in support.
In utterers meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning, grice offers a. He did so as part of his attempt to define cogitative. The philosophy of language lecture seven 10ptgrices theory of. Fodor j a 1975 the language of thought new york crowell.
And finally, i base my account of speaker meaning and addressee. Traditional and analytical philosophy by ernst tugendhat. Grice s project, which remains controversial, was to demonstrate that the primary notion of meaning was explicable in terms of the intentions of an utterer to induce in the audience certain states of belief. Although trained in heideggerian phenomenological and hermeneutical thinking, tugendhat increasingly came to believe that the most appropriate approach to philosophy was an analytical one. Intention, interpretation, and contemporary visual art. Foundations of language, 4, 225242 chapter 6 of grice, 1989. The hard task he faces is to say what type of intention creates meaning. The result of completion andor expansion is what i call conversational impliciture. Absolute intentionalism holds that a work s meaning and the artist s intentions with regard to a work s meaning are logically equivalent. Wikipedia grice further develop his theory of meaning in the 5th and 6th of his william james lectures on logic and conversation, delivered at harvard in 1967. A trust which rewards us in the most magical of ways. Pragmatics and nonverbal communication by tim wharton. Here are five steps for harnessing the power of intention to create anything you desire. His philosophy was heavily influenced by the works of franz brentano and bernard bolzano, and was also influenced in various ways by interaction with contemporaries such as alexius meinong, kasimir twardowski, and gottlob frege.
They believe that the physical existence of an object is existence itself, and look down smugly on other people. Enquiries concerning human understanding and concerning the principles of morals. In order to do this, i first develop a gametheoretic model of communication which provides a set of sufficient conditions for communication. This paper extends parikhs earlier work in semantics with games of partial information and attempts to derive and represent the full content of an utterance from first principles. These two lectures were initially published as utterers meaning and intentions in 1969 and utterers meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning in 1968, and were later collected with the other lectures as the first section of studies in the way of words in 1989. Hamilton the handbook of discourse analysis blackwell handbooks in linguistics this outstanding multivolume series covers all the major subdisciplines within linguistics today and, when complete, will offer a comprehensive survey of linguistics as a whole. In this paper, i give definitions of gricean communication, speaker meaning, and addressee interpretation. Prolegomena logic and conversation further notes on logic and conversation indicative conditionals utterers meaning and intentions utterers meaning, sentencemeaning, and wordmeaning some models for. Absolute intentionalism holds that a works meaning and the artists intentions with regard to a works meaning are logically equivalent. Prolegomena logic and conversation further notes on logic and conversation indicative conditionals utterer s meaning and intentions utterer s meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning some models for. Reviews 8 theories of meaning and classifies them into 4 categories. Paul grice, utterers meaning and intentions philpapers. The two steps in intentionbased semantics are 1 to define utterers meaning in terms of speakers overt audiencedirected. Most of this research measures verbal responses, but theory of mind has its roots earlier in development.
Grandy, richard warner predominantly known for his influential contributions to the philosophy of language, h. Firstly, the respo nse must be intendedthis r ules out 3a as a c ase o f meaning nn. Grices theory is further developed in utterers meaning and intention, 78 phil. Interest in the philosophy of language has also been enduringand has blossomed anew in the past century.
This new title in the routledge series, critical concepts in philosophy, meets the need for an authoritative reference work to make sense of the subjects. Com2 is also violated when s tricks into doing something. Conversational impliciture san francisco state university. P 1969, utterers meaning and intentions, philosophical rview 78, 147177. The role and significance of the artists intention in the interpretation of works of art has been a topic of lively debate in analytic aesthetics. What a speaker says depends on the meaning of his words, to which the speaker defers. Utterers meaning, in turn, can be analyzed without semantic remainder in terms of utterers having certain intentions. Grice is also a distinguished philosopher in the areas of ethics, metaphysics, and the philosophy of mind. Interpersonal communication as social action antonella. Sentence based queries from a user are analyzed using a natural language engine to determine appropriate answers from an electronic database.
Meaning, i consider in some detail the relations between timeless meaning, applied timeless meaning, and what i am now calling utterers occasionmeaning. Most of the rest of grices paper is dedicated to spelling out a way of identifying the meaning of an individual utterance on an occasion with the content of the utterers intentions step one. This pragmatic content is sometimes identified with speaker meaning or with the thought the speaker. Meaning, intention, and inference in primate vocal. For encoderdecoder models, meaning is a property of messages. Quine, ludwig wittgenstein, donald davidson, jacques derrida, and richard rorty. I then abstract from these to derive necessary and sufficient conditions. The materialists pull everything down from the sky and out of the invisible world onto the earth as if they wanted to clench rocks and oak trees in their fists.
The author argues that thomas hobbes anticipates a set of questions about meaning and semantic order that come to fuller expression in the 20th century, in the writings of w. We propose an account of indirect forms of speech acts to request and inform based on the hypothesis that language users can recognize actions being performed by others, infer goals being sought, and cooperate in their achievement. Us7624007b2 system and method for natural language. This could work with various definitions of mintentions, but lets just use grices version. Grices project, which remains controversial, was to demonstrate that the primary notion of meaning was explicable in terms of the intentions of an utterer to induce in the audience certain states of belief. Pollack intentions in communication brings together major theorists from artificial intelligence and computer science, linguistics, philosophy, and psychology whose work develops the foundations for an account of the role of intentions in a comprehensive theory of communication. The handbook of discourse analysis pdf free download. It also discusses various ways in which this content may be indeterminate. Speaker intentions and intentionality world to word direction of fit encompasses both the directive class of speech acts e.
Mintentions the fact thatumeant something by uttering xis grounded in the fact that,forsomeaddresseea,uuttereedxintending atoproduceaparticularresponser. In this paper we explore a new theory of discourse structure that stresses the role of purpose and processing in discourse. Pdf the notions of saying and what is said are fundamental to paul grices work. But to fish this whole enterprise seems nothing more than a massive example of misapplied scholarly ingenuity. In fact this is required, given that utterers meaning makes sense only within a broadly gricean framework. Communication, meaning, and interpretation springerlink. But each manual would fit all the behaviour of the foreign speakers. The system and methods are useful for internet based search engines, as well as distributed speech recognition systems such as a clientserver system.
Meaning, i consider in some detail the relations between timeless meaning, applied timeless meaning, and what i am now calling utterer s occasion meaning. Utterers definition of utterers by the free dictionary. The handbook of discourse analysis edited by deborah schiffrin, deborah tannen, and heidi e. The latter are typically implemented on an intranet or over the internet based on user queries at his. The burgeoning field of theoryofmind research is focussed on children s understanding of the thoughts, desires, and intentions of others. It is the creative power that fulfills all of our needs, whether for money, relationships, spiritual awakening, or love. Herbert paul grice march 19 28 august 1988, usually publishing under the name h. The parents goal is to communicate information that is interesting to the child, and thus a parents intentions are partially predictable from a childs own words and intentions. In utterers meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning, grice offers a revised version of his 1957 account of utterers meaning. This is not a reflexive account because it does not include a reflexive communicative intention i. Still, recognition leaves room for deliberation so this is more than a mere cause. Attention, intentions, and the structure of discourse. For grice, speakermeaning depends in part on word meaning, which depends on utterers meaning. Wittgensteins philosophical investigations, linguistic.
The burgeoning field of theoryofmind research is focussed on childrens understanding of the thoughts, desires, and intentions of others. It became utterers meaning, speakers meaning, utterers. Edmund husserl 18591938 was an influential thinker of the first half of the twentieth century. The recognition of the intention behind x is for the audience a reason, and not merely a cause. For it is simply a fact about the way we understand languagewhether everyday speechacts or literary textsthat we do try to figure out the utterers intentions and thus make sense of their meaning to. To be sure, the utterers intention might be to defer to something else, such as the conventional meaning of a symbol, but this is just a view about the nature of the utterers intention. Grice remarks that in the earlier 1957 account i took the view that the mintended effect is, in the case of indicativestype utterance, that the hearer should believe something, and, in the case of. An intelligent query system for processing voicedbased queries is disclosed, which uses a combination of both statistical and semantic based processing to identify the question posed by the user by understanding the meaning of the users utterance. Meaning, maxims of communication and language games. This new title in the routledge series, critical concepts in philosophy, meets the need for an authoritative reference work to make sense of the subjects vast literature and the continuing explosion in research output. These two lectures were initially published as utterers meaning and intentions in 1969 and utterers meaning, sentence meaning, and word meaning in 1968, and were. Intention worksheet setting intentions relies upon us having an unwavering trust. Each theorys contribution to the current debate on what is meaning is. Starting with the assumption that the notion of an utterers occasionmeaning can be explicated, in a certain way, in terms of an utterers intentions, i.
Grice addressed the problem of word meaning very briefly in utterers. We then argue in favor of a smallscale view of communication capable of accounting for the normative effects of communicative acts. According to the evolutionary biologists john maynard smith and eors szathmary, the transition from primatelike calls to speech was the decisive step in the origin of specifically human society 1995, p. The point is developed in the writings of paul grice in a way that holds powerful significance for our understanding of musical, and particularly compositional, meaning but well beyond the scope of the present project. To see the idea as initially outlined in grices 1957 article, meaning, imagine you are stopped at night at an intersection, when the driver in an oncoming car flashes her lights. Authors intentions, literary interpretation, and literary. To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an updatecorrectionremoval request. Based on identifying the meaning of the utterance, the system selects a single answer that best matches the users query. Create an affirmation that makes your soul stir and your heart swell. Now some question may be raised about my use, fairly free. In this theory, discourse structure is composed of three separate but interrelated components. A defense of procedural individualism mark bevir many historians of religion, literary historians, and other textual scholars have understood their task to be the recovery of authorial intentions. I also benefitted greatly from the suggestions of an anonymous referee for this journal. They grasp them, and stubbornly maintain that the only objects that exist are those that are tangible and comprehensible.
Utterer definition of utterer by the free dictionary. Us7725321b2 speech based query system using semantic. The aesthetic relevance of authors and painters intentions. What matters to successful linguistic communication is the intention of the speaker to be in.
144 1077 1326 759 511 1227 70 853 970 1304 393 809 1175 1626 1327 1063 969 1057 319 1624 696 1058 65 1508 1035 940 471 1069 893 656 62